The U.S. Jumped into the ICJ case South Africa brought against Israel over genocide allegations in Gaza, calling them false and arguing the court shouldn't weaken international law.
In a filing The AP obtained Thursday, the U.S. Directly rejected South Africa's core argument. The U.S. Argues these accusations are part of a "broader campaign" against Israel and the Jewish people, intended "to justify or encourage terrorism against them."
South Africa first brought the case to the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in December 2023. It alleges Israel's military campaign in Gaza, launched after Hamas-led attacks on October 7, 2023, breaches the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. Israel, founded after the Holocaust, has vehemently denied these accusations, maintaining its actions are self-defense.
Washington's Stance on Intent
The U.S. Stressed that you have to prove specific intent to establish genocide. It cautions the court, which sits in The Hague, against "lowering the standard" for this crucial legal threshold.
State Department legal adviser Reed Rubenstein, representing the U.S., stressed how serious these accusations are. He told the AP that a finding against Israel would represent a "radical repudiation" of the court's established precedent.
Such a decision, Rubenstein argued, would "feed the perception that the court is simply just one more tool in the ongoing pro-Hamas lawfare campaign" against Israel.
The U.S. Filing makes an obvious point: widespread civilian deaths don't automatically mean genocide was intended. That's especially true when deaths happen in urban warfare. To prove genocide, the U.S. Argues, destroying a protected group has to be the only logical explanation for what happened. Because genocide is so serious, the ICJ needs to be absolutely certain before ruling on it.
A Divided International Response
Under Article 63 of the ICJ statute, any country that signed the Genocide Convention can jump in and argue about the legal issues. Over 30 countries sided with Ukraine against Russia in 2023, but the Israel case has split the world differently.
More than a dozen other countries have also filed interventions in the Israel case, including Spain, the Netherlands, Ireland, Namibia, Hungary, Fiji, Iceland, Belgium, Brazil, Belize, Colombia, Mexico, and Turkey. Many disagree with the U.S., backing South Africa's claims or interpreting the Genocide Convention differently.
The Netherlands and Iceland filed declarations earlier this week raising red flags about Israel's conduct. The Netherlands—where the ICJ sits—argued that displacing over 1 million people, killing more than 20,000 children, and blocking aid to starve the population all point to genocide when you look at what Israeli officials have said. This Dutch told judges to look at starvation and aid blockades as evidence of intent, especially if there's a clear pattern.
Iceland—filing its first real ICJ case—zeroed in on how Israel treated children in Gaza. Iceland said attacks on kids—killing them or hurting them—deserve close attention because they show intent to wipe out a group. South Africa pointed to Israeli leaders using genocidal language, mass killings, destroyed infrastructure, and conditions that threaten Palestinian survival.
ICJ's Previous Orders and Ongoing Conflict
Since South Africa filed in December 2023, the ICJ has handed down several temporary orders about Israel's actions in Gaza. The court told Israel to do everything it can to stop deaths, destruction, and genocide. It also ordered Israel to get basic services and humanitarian aid to Gaza. In other proceedings, the court told Israel to let UNRWA deliver aid to Gaza.
Gaza keeps drawing global attention, and groups like Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and B'Tselem agree with some countries that Israel's actions might be genocide. Gaza's health ministry says over 72,000 people died since October 2023, but independent groups think the real number is higher. A U.S.-brokered ceasefire last year cut down the worst fighting and got more aid in, but the U.S. And Israel tightened restrictions again when they hit Iran.
Related Articles
- RemeGen lands US$650m upfront, keeps Greater China rights
- Copper slips as China holiday reshapes positions
- China rare‑earth stocks jump up to 18% after Beijing tightens rules
The ICC separately issued arrest warrants for Netanyahu and his ex-defense minister for alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity in Gaza.
This article was created with AI assistance.
